top of page

"I don't have the Authority," Negotiation hardball Tactic

Have you ever approached your manager for a pay raise, only to be met with the response that they don't have the authority to increase your salary? If this sounds familiar, you might be facing a classic negotiation scenario where hardball tactics are at play.

When your manager uses the phrase “I don’t have the authority,” it’s possible that they are indeed bound by company policies or budget constraints.

Negotiation Hardball Tactics
Courtesy - Unsplash

However, it’s equally possible that this is a hardball negotiation tactic designed to deflect your request. This hardball negotiation tactic of commitment is used to establish a firm boundary that essentially cannot be crossed, often without any room for flexibility or discussion.

Commitment Tactics in Negotiation

Commitment tactics in negotiation involve a negotiator asserting that they have limited ability to offer concessions or make decisions. This stance can manifest in various forms, such as claiming to have their "hands tied" by company policies, predetermined budgets, or higher authority approvals. These tactics create a sense of inflexibility, signaling that the negotiator’s capacity to alter terms is strictly confined. Whether true or not, these tactics put pressure on the other party to reconsider their demands and accept the offer on the table, often without pushing further.

Understanding: Genuine Limits or a Negotiation hardball tactic

Genuine limits often have a basis in organizational structure, legal regulations, or budgetary caps that are indeed outside the negotiator's control. On the other hand, a strategic move may be employed to create a sense of urgency or to end the negotiation swiftly on terms favorable to them.

In order to understand more, pay attention to the context of the negotiation, historical behaviors of your manager, and any evidence that supports their claims. Also consider the level of authority your manager has. If he or she is a director above they were chosen because they can indeed make decisions, making claims of limited discretion a tactic rather than a reality.

The Importance of Recognizing and Responding to Commitment Tactics

It's important to identify these tactics. If these tactics are not identified and responded to effectively, you may leave value on the table or make unnecessary concessions. Responding to them requires a mix of strategic questioning, emotional intelligence, and sometimes, calling the bluff or requesting to engage with someone who has the purported necessary authority.

Techniques for Countering This negotiation hardball Tactic When Negotiating a Pay Raise

When your manager uses commitment tactics during a negotiation for a pay raise, it can be disheartening. However, with the right approach, you can counter these tactics effectively. The key is to expand the conversation, test the flexibility of any supposed limits, and employ incremental bargaining.

Here’s how to tackle each of these steps:

Using “What If” Scenarios to Expand the Conversation

‘What if’ scenarios allow you to explore possibilities beyond the apparent limits set by your manager without directly challenging their authority. For example:

  • What if we re-evaluate my salary after a set period of demonstrated performance improvements?

  • What if we consider non-monetary compensation, such as additional vacation time, until a raise is feasible?

  • What if I take on more responsibilities that justify a higher pay grade?

  • What if we review my flex work schedule request?

Think creatively here. These scenarios show your willingness to collaborate and find a mutual agreement, and they might reveal more room for maneuver than previously indicated by your manager’s stance.

Testing the Flexibility of the Supposed Limits

Even if your manager has indicated that a pay raise is not currently possible, it’s important to understand the nuances of this limitation. Ask probing questions that can help clarify the exact boundaries of their authority:

  • Could you help me understand the budget constraints we're facing? When are the constraints no longer applicable?

  • What is the company policy that dictates pay raise approvals, and can we review it together?

  • At what levels of performance or profit does the company typically consider salary reviews?

The answers to these questions can give you valuable insight into the true flexibility of the situation.

Incremental Bargaining: Gradually Working Towards Your Goal

Incremental bargaining involves making smaller, more manageable requests that can lead to your ultimate goal over time. Instead of a significant pay raise all at once, consider what intermediate steps could be acceptable:

  • What if we did a two-step pay raise? e.g. Could we agree on a smaller pay raise now with a plan to revisit this conversation in six months?

  • What performance targets can we set that would make a pay raise a more acceptable proposal to the higher management?

By breaking down your request, you can potentially bypass your manager’s immediate constraints and set a path forward.

ASK "How Can You Help Me?"

End by asking your manager directly but respectfully for assistance. This transforms the negotiation from a confrontation to a collaborative discussion and reinforces the idea that you’re seeking a solution together:

  • Given these constraints, how can you help me get the visibility so I can achieve a fair compensation for my contributions to the team?

  • I understand your position; what would you suggest as the best course of action for me to get the raise.

  • What projects will allow me to get a promotion so I can get a higher pay?

This approach can encourage your manager to think creatively and become an ally in your pursuit of a raise, rather than an obstacle.

Remember that pacing can significantly influence the outcome. Allowing for breaks in the negotiation process serves a dual purpose. It not only provides you with the opportunity to reassess the situation, gather additional information, and consult with mentors or peers, but it also grants both parties a moment to reflect away from the pressure of the negotiation table. This breathing space can soften entrenched positions and open up new avenues for discussion upon reconvening.

Finally remember - patience, combined with a steady and methodical approach, can often lead to improvements that seemed improbable in the face of initial commitment tactics. Whether you secure the pay raise now or lay the groundwork for a future agreement, understanding and applying these tactics will prepare you for the long haul!

I have created a word-for-word script - download here, prior to having your pay raise conversation!

3 views0 comments


bottom of page